Sherlock

The BBC’s new Sherlock Holmes series Sherlock (co-created by Doctor Who head writer Steven Moffat) had its American debut last night. I actually watched it over the summer, having acquired it through quasi-legal means, and if it’s running in your market, then you should make every effort to watch it. It may be my new favorite thing.
I knew who Sherlock Holmes was before I ever learned to read, and one of the first “chapter books” I ever read was a collection of Sherlock Homes short stories. I’ve made the pilgrimage to 221B Baker street, and I’m pretty certain I’ve written Sherlock Holmes fan fiction at some point (at the very least, I’ve dreamed it). I love Holmes.
Other than Hamlet, there’s no character in English literature that’s so much larger than the stories that (seek to) contain him, and this new series of BBC films, which updates the character (and his near-equal companion Watson) to 21st century London, captures the spirit of Holmes and in some ways improves on the stories of Arthur Conan Doyle.
<Spoilers>
The first of the films finds Dr. John Watson returning to London from military service in Afghanistan after being wounded (just like the original). Depressed and bored with civilian life, and also short on money, he takes rooms with an acquaintance of a friend, Sherlock Holmes.
The Holmes of the new series isn’t a hero. He’s a borderline psychopath, similar to the Holmes-inspired physician Dr. Gregory House but not weighed down by the cliché formula of a medical procedural.
There was always this subtext in the original stories. The conventions of the mystery story required Holmes to keep Watson (and therefore the reader) in the dark about a number of details, even if it annoyed or endangered his companion. In the new series, Holmes constantly abandons his companion, or sends him on sometimes pointless errands, because he has almost no regard for other people. They exist only when they interest him., and the people that interest him most are criminals, especially murderers.
The link between Holmes and the killers he hunts is made explicit when a minor character remarks that one day it will be Holmes that they’re investigating. at the same time, his fascination with the criminal mind almost brings him to an untimely end.
</spoilers>
If I’ve ever steered you right with a recommendation, then heed my advice and watch Sherlock now. There are two more films in the first series, and they’re every bit as good.



